Introduction
The Second Sunday of Easter always carries a different energy than the week before.
Easter Sunday bursts with sound and color. Sanctuaries are full. Trumpets ring. The alleluias that were buried during Lent finally return. Even people who rarely attend church find their way into a pew.
But a week later, things feel quieter.
The lilies are still there, but they’re beginning to droop. The extra chairs are gone. The rhythm of ordinary life begins to return. The church moves from celebration back into something closer to normal.
And it’s precisely here, after the excitement fades, that the church hears one of the most important resurrection stories in the Gospel of John.
Because resurrection is not only about what happened on Easter morning. It is about what kind of community Jesus forms in the days that follow.
Narrative Context
John places this moment on the evening of Easter Day itself.
The disciples are gathered together behind locked doors. The text tells us plainly why: fear. Their teacher has just been executed by the empire with the cooperation of religious authorities. Being publicly associated with him could easily put them at risk as well.
So they do what frightened people often do. They gather together and close the doors.
And then Jesus appears among them.
There is no dramatic entrance described. No knocking at the door. No puff of smoke or bright light. No explanation of how he arrived. Simply, Jesus standing among them and speaks the first words of resurrection life to his friends.
“Peace be with you.”
He shows them his hands and his side, the marks of crucifixion still visible on his body. The risen Christ is not detached from suffering. Resurrection does not erase the wounds. Instead, the wounds become part of the story the disciples must now carry into the world.
Then Jesus repeats the greeting: “Peace be with you.”
And with those words he gives them their first commission.
“As the Father has sent me, so I send you.”
Immediately after this, Jesus breathes on them and says, “Receive the Holy Spirit.” It is a moment that echoes the creation story itself, God breathing life into humanity. A new creation is beginning.
And then comes the line that often surprises us: “If you forgive the sins of any, they are forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they are retained.”
Before sermons are preached, before churches are planted, before the disciples travel anywhere at all, the first work Jesus gives them is the work of forgiveness.
Unlocking Forgiveness
In many ways, forgiveness is the quiet emphasis of the resurrection community.
Think about who is in that locked room. These are the same disciples who fled when Jesus was arrested. Peter has denied even knowing him. Others disappeared when the cross appeared on the horizon. Their last collective memory as disciples is failure.
But that is not the only thing they carry into that room.
They have also just witnessed violence. They saw their teacher publicly humiliated, tortured, and executed. They watched the machinery of empire and religious authority crush someone they loved. The cross is not just a theological symbol to them yet. It is still a symbol of imperial violence.
People who have lived through something like that could easily become bitter.
They could blame the religious leaders who handed Jesus over.
They could hate the Roman soldiers who carried out the execution.
They could distrust the crowds who turned so quickly.
They could retreat into anger, suspicion, and judgment of the world around them.
And if we are honest, that response would be understandable.
But when Jesus appears in the room, he does not fan those flames. He does not direct their anger toward their enemies. He does not give them a mission of settling scores, seeking vengeance, or proving others wrong.
Instead, he offers them peace.
After all of the horrors he has just endured, after what his mind, body, and heart have been through, the first words out of Jesus’ mouth are “Peace.”
Not once.
But twice.
Then he entrusts them with the very thing they themselves have just experienced: forgiveness.
The disciples are not sent because they were brave enough or faithful enough. They are sent because they have encountered mercy. And that mercy must now shape how they see the world.
In other words, the resurrection community will be made up of people who have every reason to be bitter, and yet are called to forgive.
But forgiveness in that room is not only about what the disciples will offer to others. It is also about what they must learn to receive for themselves.
Because the people sitting in that locked room are not only grieving what happened to Jesus. They are also carrying the weight of how they themselves responded to it. They ran. They hid. Peter denied even knowing him. Others disappeared when things became dangerous. Their last memories before the cross are not heroic ones. They are memories of failure.
And it is very easy for people to live trapped inside those memories. Sometimes the hardest person to forgive is not an enemy. Sometimes it is ourselves.
We replay the moment we should have spoken up but didn’t.
The time we misunderstood someone we loved.
The decision we wish we could undo.
The disciples know that feeling. And Jesus knows it too.
That may be part of why his first words are peace.
Before they are sent into the world to forgive others, they must first receive the peace and mercy standing right in front of them. They must learn that their failure is not the end of their story.
Only forgiven people can become forgiving people.
Because if we are still guarding our own shame and regret, we will often project it outward. The things we struggle to forgive in ourselves (betrayal, stubbornness, misunderstanding) we begin to see everywhere in others.
But when forgiveness takes root in our own hearts, something begins to loosen.
The walls come down.
The doors begin to open.
And the resurrection community becomes a place where mercy is practiced again and again.
Which means that in that locked room on Easter evening, Jesus is not only restoring frightened disciples.
He is forming the foundation of the church.
A church made up of people who have been forgiven.
People who are still learning to forgive themselves.
And people who are sent into the world to extend that same mercy to others.
Preaching Possibility
Choosing Forgiveness in a Wounded World
For many congregations, this passage becomes centered on Thomas and his doubt. But the larger story here is about the kind of community resurrection creates.
Jesus gives the disciples authority to forgive.
That might sound like a comforting spiritual idea, but when we remember the context, it becomes much more challenging. The disciples have just lived through trauma. They have seen injustice and cruelty firsthand. They have every reason to carry anger into the future.
And yet the first work Jesus gives them is not revenge. It is not judgment.
It is forgiveness.
This does not mean pretending that the violence of the cross did not happen. The risen Christ still bears the wounds in his hands and side. Resurrection does not erase suffering or deny injustice.
But it does mean refusing to let bitterness have the final word.
That challenge remains just as real for the church today.
We live in a world that often runs on outrage. News cycles thrive on anger. Social media rewards quick judgment. Communities fracture over politics, culture, and identity. Many people carry wounds from betrayal, misunderstanding, and deep disagreement.
And beneath much of that conflict sits another quieter struggle: the difficulty of forgiving ourselves.
People carry regret for things they have said, things they failed to say, relationships that broke, decisions they wish they could undo. Shame has a way of locking doors just as tightly as fear.
But resurrection begins in locked rooms.
Jesus steps into spaces filled with fear, regret, and uncertainty and speaks the same words he spoke to the disciples: “Peace be with you.”
That peace is not a denial of the past. The wounds are still visible. But it is a declaration that failure, betrayal, and violence will not have the final word.
And from that place of mercy, Jesus sends his followers into the world.
Not as people who have everything figured out.
But as people who know what it means to be forgiven.
The church at its best becomes a community where that mercy is practiced again and again. A place where people learn, slowly and imperfectly, to release bitterness toward others and to loosen the grip of shame within themselves.
In a wounded world, forgiveness is not easy work.
But it may be some of the most important resurrection work the church has been given to do.
Because every time forgiveness breaks through anger, every time mercy interrupts shame, every time a door that was locked begins to open, the life of the risen Christ is already at work among us.
Micah Krey 
Leave a comment